Expert Comments

US Commerce Dept. seeks enhanced EU-U.S. Privacy Shield

Expert(s): Security Experts
Expert(s): Security Experts

The US Department of Commerce, in a joint press release with the European Commission, is calling for an enhanced EU-U.S. Privacy Shield framework to comply with the July 16th judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union in the Schrems II case, which ruled the current EU-US framework “is no longer a valid mechanism to transfer personal data from the European Union to the United States.”  (Note: Mr. Schrems claimed in a complaint against Facebook Ireland that the United States does not offer sufficient protection of data transferred to other countries. The case is seen to have broad implications on the enforcement of GDPR data transfer privacy requirements.)

Experts Comments

August 13, 2020
Dan Piazza
Technical Product Manager
Stealthbits Technologies
The EU and the U.S. are working on a new Privacy Shield agreement, however, there's much room for skepticism after both Safe Harbor and the first Privacy Shield were struck down by the European Court of Justice over the past few years. A joint statement between the U.S. Secretary of Commerce and the EU Commissioner for Justice states the two sides are working towards a new agreement, however, it all seems to be hand waving at this point until the U.S. government makes drastic changes to.....Read More
The EU and the U.S. are working on a new Privacy Shield agreement, however, there's much room for skepticism after both Safe Harbor and the first Privacy Shield were struck down by the European Court of Justice over the past few years. A joint statement between the U.S. Secretary of Commerce and the EU Commissioner for Justice states the two sides are working towards a new agreement, however, it all seems to be hand waving at this point until the U.S. government makes drastic changes to national data security policy and procedure. Privacy Shield was struck down primarily because federal U.S. security agencies, such as the NSA, have too much access to personal information stored by U.S. tech companies and other organizations. Without drastic reform to data privacy standards in the U.S., and the reach of agencies like the NSA, any potential new Privacy Shield agreements will most likely be swiftly shut down by the same court in the EU. It's clear the U.S. needs a mechanism like Privacy Shield in place, however, so far, the U.S. government hasn't taken any clear action that indicates they intend to start taking data privacy more seriously.  Read Less
August 13, 2020
Saryu Nayyar
CEO
Gurucul
Europe's top court struck down Privacy Shield, and Safe Harbor before it, is really no surprise. The internet spans the globe, with data going everywhere, all the time, for billions of users. While the internet was hailed as a borderless platform to bring the world together, the reality is each region has its own concerns and laws governing it. This is a perfect example of exactly that. The European Union puts data privacy for its citizens first, ahead of Law Enforcement and State needs......Read More
Europe's top court struck down Privacy Shield, and Safe Harbor before it, is really no surprise. The internet spans the globe, with data going everywhere, all the time, for billions of users. While the internet was hailed as a borderless platform to bring the world together, the reality is each region has its own concerns and laws governing it. This is a perfect example of exactly that. The European Union puts data privacy for its citizens first, ahead of Law Enforcement and State needs. The US puts National Security and Law Enforcement interests ahead of personal privacy. It's a fundamental difference in perspective, which makes it difficult for businesses to navigate the legal hurdles while simultaneously complying with conflicting regulations on a global scale. Finding common ground will take negotiation and compromise, but it is vital. The data must flow.  Read Less

Submit Your Expert Comments

What do you think of the topic? Do you agree with expert(s) or share your expert opinion below.
Be part of our growing Information Security Expert Community (1000+), please register here.

Write Your Expert Comments *
Your Registered Email *
Notification Email (If different from your registered email)
* By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this web site.
SUBMIT

You may also like

Booz Allen Report On CISOs And China Quantum Computing Risks,...

Experts Reactions On Sky Broadband Hack Warning

Ransomware Set To Break Records This Black Friday 2021

Security Expert On Apple Suing NSO Group

Meta Delays Plans To Rollout End-to-end Encryption

NCSC Issues Black Friday Warning To Tetailers

How The Zelle Fraud Scam Steals Your Bank Credentials

GoDaddy Data Breach Impacts Over A Million Users, Experts Reactions

Utah Imaging Data Breach – Expert Comments

Telecoms Security Bill – What’s Missing?

Information Security Buzz (aka ISBuzz News) is an independent resource that provides the experts comments, analysis and opinion on the latest Information Security news and topics

Twitter Facebook-f Linkedin Youtube

Working With Us

The Pages

Our Contributing Experts